Why Dave Ramsey is Wrong On Mutual Funds
Dave is Right on Many Things But Here's Where He Gets Mutual Funds Wrong
Dave Ramsey's advice on mutual funds is fundamentally correct and even wise but some of his key points, especially on asset allocation and diversification, he gets terribly wrong.
If you've been saving money, trying to get out of debt, investing in mutual funds or you just like listening to talk radio, Dave Ramsey needs no introduction. I was an early listener of his personal finance radio show (dating back to the mid-90's) and I own the first printing of his now famous book, Financial Peace, which remains on my shelf to this day.
In fact, Dave deserves credit for helping me understand and enjoy personal finance, which eventually led to my career as an investment advisor. I am now a Certified Financial Planner (TM) and I own a fee-only Registered Investment Advisory firm.
This general respect of Dave Ramsey, combined with extensive financial services background and mutual funds expertise, makes me qualified to provide some insight into the best and worst of Dave's investment advice (although he's not licensed to sell securities and does not technically call it "advice").
What Dave Ramsey Gets Right
Ramsey, the investment advice and financial planning guru, gives his radio show listeners and book readers sage financial planning advice in many ways but he gives some poor advice on mutual funds. Dave's best value to his audience is that his message is simple, easy to understand and often entertaining. He also focuses on the psychology of money; Dave knows that an investor's worst enemy is often themselves.
In my experience, I know that if goals are not attainable and easy to understand, people fail early or they don't even make an attempt to reach a goal. This is true with financial goals, food diets, exercise programs and just about anything that requires motivation, time and patience.
Ignorance and the failure to act are often more dangerous behaviors in personal finance than applying less-than-ideal investment philosophies.
Therefore, Dave's simple delivery and his "baby steps" to financial freedom are effective in pointing people in the right general direction than much of the complexity and noise in other parts of the financial services universe.
However, with regard to mutual funds in specific, Dave Ramsey's investment philosophies are bordering on dangerous. Mutual fund investors can get some good tips from his talk radio show but they are wise to understand the difference between entertainment and sound investment practices.
The Dave Ramsey Investing Philosophy
To be completely fair, let's begin with Dave's Investing Philosophy, specifically regarding mutual funds, taken directly from his website:
Dave recommends mutual funds for your employer-sponsored retirement savings and your IRAs. Divide your investments equally between each of these four types of funds:
- Growth & Income
- Aggressive Growth
Choose A shares (front end load) and funds that are at least five years old. They should have a solid track record of acceptable returns within their fund category.
If your risk tolerance is low, which means you have a shorter time to keep your money invested, put less than 25% in aggressive growth or consider adding a "Balanced" fund to the four types of funds suggested.
Dave Ramsey's Poor Asset Allocation: Where's the Bonds?
One of the most fundamental aspects of asset allocation is to have more than one asset type. Dave Ramsey's 4-fund mix includes only one asset type; there are only stock funds, no bond funds or cash (money market or stable value). A portfolio consisting of 100% stocks is simply inappropriate for the vast majority of Dave's audience and, in the opinion of your humble mutual funds guide, an asset allocation of 100% stock funds is wrong for most human beings on the planet.
Dave Ramsey's 4-fund Mix: Overlap Reduces Diversification
In the Dave Ramsey mutual fund investment strategy, he urges investors to hold 4 mutual funds in their 401(k) or IRA -- one Growth fund, one Growth & Income fund, one Aggressive Growth fund and one International fund.
This 4-fund mix has great potential for overlap, which occurs when an investor owns two or more mutual funds that hold similar securities. Following Dave's example, imagine an inexperienced investor looking at their 401(k) plan, which offers Vanguard mutual funds:
A common investment choice is Vanguard S&P 500 Index (VFINX). The beginning investor would not know if this fund was "growth" or "growth & income" or neither. Also, what if another choice in the plan was Vanguard Growth & Income (VQNPX)? Would the investor know if there was overlap? Here's how they can find out (although Dave might not tell them this). They (or you) can go to Morningstar.com and enter a search for VQNPX. Once on that fund's main page, look for a link to "Ratings and Risk" and click on it. When on that page, scroll down and you'll see something called R-squared and that it is 99. This means that VQNPX has a 99% correlation to the S&P 500 index fund; they are virtually identical!
Making things worse, an investor may understandably think any international stock fund won't invest in stock found in their domestic growth or growth & income fund. However, if the fund is categorized as "world stock," it can invest anywhere between 20% and 60% in US stocks. This creates more overlap (less diversification).
In summary, Dave's 4-fund mix could potentially have the same diversification as just one or two stock funds. If and when US stock prices fall, an investor's account value could fall much more than if they had a diverse mix of stock funds and bond funds. This kind of loss of account value is what frustrates investors and makes them stop investing altogether.
Where's the No-Load Funds in Dave Ramsey's Advice?
In his investment philosophy, Dave says to use A shares (loaded funds), which means the investor will pay commissions to a broker or investment advisor (in an IRA or brokerage account). Why wouldn't Dave recommend no-load funds? My first guess is because Dave tells his listeners to use an "Endorsed Local Provider (ELP)". This is a broker or advisor that Dave recommends (although I suspect these ELPs also advertise on Dave's show). I wonder why he wouldn't help his audience invest for themselves or suggest using a "fee-only" advisor that can recommend no-load funds -- and advisor who only gets paid for the unbiased advice they give and not the products they sell?
Dave Ramsey's Definition of Risk Tolerance is Wrong
Dave says that investors may need to adjust the aggressive portion of the portfolio if their risk tolerance is low and he says risk tolerance "means you have a shorter time to keep your money invested." No, the amount of time is the investor's time horizon, which is measured from today until to the end of the investment objective or savings goal, which has nothing to do with risk tolerance. The true definition of risk tolerance refers to the amount of market risk, especially the volatility (ups and downs), an investor can tolerate. An 80-year old can have a high risk tolerance and a 20-year old can have a low risk tolerance. The amount of risk an investor can tolerate is completely about emotions or feelings, not an amount of time.
What Dave Ramsey probably means when he says risk tolerance is what I call "risk capacity," which is the amount of risk someone can "afford" to take. For example, even if you consider yourself an aggressive investor (high risk tolerance), it may not be wise to have 100% of your retirement savings in stocks just one year before you plan to retire. Likewise, if you have 40 years until retirement (long time horizon, high risk capacity) but you have low risk tolerance, you won't be served well by putting all of your 401(k) money in a stable value fund.
I gave you some clues about how to correct some of Dave's bad mutual fund advice but in this second part of our feature on Dave Ramsey's mutual fund advice, we'll cover all of the best ideas Dave shares with his audience, along with a few he could do a better job of communicating.
A List of the Best Basics of Investing With Mutual Funds
- Learn how to build a portfolio: Everything from asset allocation to risk tolerance to portfolio strategy is here. If you like all of this information in one place check out this article. However if you only need a few pieces, the following links break it down further...
- Use a Core and Satellite Portfolio Design: This mutual fund portfolio structure is just as it sounds. You select a "core" fund and build around it with "satellite" funds. For example a good core is an S&P 500 Index fund, at around 40% allocation, and other diverse categories, such as Foreign Stock, Small-cap stock and Bond funds, at around 10 to 20% each.
- Be Sure to Use Diverse Fund Categories: This is at the root of the Dave Ramsey portfolio weakness. Dave's 4 fund categories are all similar in their make up, which creates a ticking time bomb of poor diversification called overlap. For example, 3 of the 4 groups Dave recommends (growth, growth & income and aggressive growth) could all be large-cap domestic stock funds. This area of the market was one of the worst during the 2007 to 2009 bear market. A diversified portfolio would have prevented this problem.
- Know the Definition of Risk Tolerance: As I said on Page 1 of this article, Dave explains it completely wrong when he says low risk tolerance "means you have a shorter time to keep your money invested." Time has nothing to do with tolerance! Time is measured in months or years and tolerance is an attitude, feeling or emotion about the ups and downs of your account balance. Also, risk tolerance is normally guaged by questionnaires that can arrive at inaccurate results. For example, some of the questions ask how you might feel if you lost 20% of your account value over the course of a few months or a year. What would you do: Sell now, wait and decide later or would you do nothing? This is like asking, "What would you do if your best friend was in a car accident: Freak out, stay calm and help her, or call 911?" There's no real way of knowing unless you've recently been in the same situation.
- Decide An Appropriate Asset Allocation: Once you determine your level of risk tolerance, you can determine your asset allocation, which is the mix of investment assets—stocks, bonds and cash—that comprises your portfolio. The proper asset allocation will reflect your level of risk tolerance, which can be described as either aggressive (high tolerance for risk), moderate (medium risk tolerance) or conservative (low risk tolerance).
- Learn How to Choose the Best Funds For Yourself: Dave Ramsey helps beginners at the very minimum by encouraging them to invest in mutual funds but he gives very little detail about how to choose the best funds. All you really need is a good mutual fund research site and remember to look for low expense ratios as well as good long-term performance history (at least 5 years). Also, be sure to use no-load funds, rather than the A share (loaded) funds Dave suggests on his website.
Simple Examples of Constructing the Best Portfolio of Mutual Funds for You
It always helps to do another review and do more homework. If you want a nice shortcut (because I know that a simple guide is how most people prefer to learn), here are some sample portfolios:
- Aggressive (High Risk) Portfolio Example: This is for investors who have time horizons of 10 or more years and can hold on during periods of extreme volatility (ups and downs) of the market.
- Moderate (Medium Risk) Portfolio Example: This is for investors who have time horizons of 5 or more years and can only tolerate medium swings in account value.
- Conservative (Low Risk) Portfolio Example: This is for investors who have time horizons of 3 or more years and have low tolerance for fluctuations in account value.
Elsewhere on the web, you can check out this article on the blog, Bad Money Advice, Ten Things Dave Ramsey Got Wrong. I also recommend reading the comments section of the blog post for more opinions from readers.
Disclaimer: The information on this site is provided for discussion purposes only, and should not be misconstrued as investment advice. Under no circumstances does this information represent a recommendation to buy or sell securities.